Prevalence of and Risk Factors for Post–COVID-19 Condition during Omicron BA.5–Dominant Wave, Japan

The increased risk for post–COVID-19 condition after the Omicron-dominant wave remains unclear. This population-based study included 25,911 persons in Japan 20–69 years of age with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection enrolled in the established registry system during July–August 2022 and 25,911 age- and sex-matched noninfected controls who used a self-reported questionnaire in January–February 2023. We compared prevalence and age- and sex-adjusted odds ratios of persistent COVID-19 symptoms (lasting ≥2 months). We evaluated factors associated with post–COVID-19 condition by comparing cases with and without post–COVID-19 condition. We analyzed 14,710 (8,392 cases and 6,318 controls) of 18,183 respondents. Post–COVID-19 condition proportion among cases was 11.8%, higher by 6.3% than 5.5% persistent symptoms among controls. Female sex, underlying medical conditions, mild to moderate acute COVID-19, and vaccination were associated with post–COVID-19 condition. Approximately 12% had post–COVID-19 condition during the Omicron-dominant wave, indicating the need for longer follow-up.

The increased risk for post-COVID-19 condition after the Omicron-dominant wave remains unclear.This population-based study included 25,911 persons in Japan 20-69 years of age with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection enrolled in the established registry system during July-August 2022 and 25,911 age-and sex-matched noninfected controls who used a self-reported questionnaire in January-February 2023.We compared prevalence and age-and sex-adjusted odds ratios of persistent COVID-19 symptoms (lasting ≥2 months).We evaluated factors associated with post-COVID-19 condition by comparing cases with and without post-COVID-19 condition.We analyzed 14,710 (8,392 cases and 6,318 controls) of 18,183 respondents.Post-COVID-19 condition proportion among cases was 11.8%, higher by 6.3% than 5.5% persistent symptoms among controls.Female sex, underlying medical conditions, mild to moderate acute COVID-19, and vaccination were associated with post-COVID-19 condition.Approximately 12% had post-COVID-19 condition during the Omicron-dominant wave, indicating the need for longer follow-up.compared with a noninfected population, focusing specifically on the Omicron variant (especially the BA.5 lineage).We also investigated the factors associated with post-COVID-19 condition.

Study Design and Participants
We conducted a population-based study of community-dwelling adults 20-69 years of age who had confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection during July-August 2022.We extracted data from the Japan Health Center Real-time Information-sharing System on COVID-19 (HER-SYS), the established registry system, and age-and sex-matched controls using a self-reported web-based questionnaire in Shinagawa City, a metropolitan area located in the Tokyo area of Japan.The population of Shinagawa City is ≈400,000 and its population density is 17,700 persons/km 2 .
Japan experienced the 7th wave of COVID-19 in July 2022, caused by the Omicron subvariant BA.5 lineage.The prevalence of the BA.5 lineage increased from 67% in epidemiologic week 27 (July 7-10, 2022) to 92% in epidemiologic week 30 (July 25-31, 2022), becoming dominant (25).When COVID-19 was diagnosed by a positive reverse transcription PCR or a lateral flow antigen test for SARS-CoV-2 or a clinical diagnosis (for symptomatic close contacts), the attending physician was required to document every case in HER-SYS until September 26, 2022.Patients needed to see a physician to undergo a test for SARS-CoV-2 until the Ministry of Health, Labour, and Welfare approved over-the-counter antigen test kits on August 24, 2022.However, most patients visited a physician even after the over-the-counter antigen test kits became available rather than testing themselves at home.Therefore, most of the infected persons were registered in HER-SYS during the study period.
We selected participants registered in the HER-SYS database who were 20-69 years of age and infected with SARS-CoV-2 during July 1-August 31, 2022.We excluded 3,365 of the 29,276 identified infected residents who had died or moved out of the area and selected the remaining 25,911 infected persons as study participants (infected group).We matched data from HER-SYS and the Basic Resident Registration system (the municipal residence record of the name, birthdate, sex, and address of all residents living in a municipality) to identify noninfected residents who had never been registered in the HER-SYS database during the participant selection.We selected 25,911 age-and sex-matched noninfected persons (noninfected group) from the matched dataset (Figure 1).The ethics committee of the National Center for Global Health and Medicine approved this study (NCGM-S-004571).
We sent research information and invitations to the online questionnaire to the selected participants Post-COVID Condition during Omicron-Dominant Wave (25,911 each in the infected and noninfected group) by mail on January 11-13, 2023, approximately 6 months after infection for those who had COVID-19 (cases).Respondents were required to provide consent to participate in the study before accessing the website; those who agreed answered the questionnaire by February 13.At the beginning of the questionnaire, we asked participants if they had a diagnosis of COVID-19.If they answered "yes," they were directed to the questions for infected persons, which inquired about the number and date of infection episodes.If they answered "no," "I don't know," or "I prefer not to answer," they were directed to the questions for noninfected persons (Appendix, https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/EID/article/30/7/23-1723-App1.pdf).We included persons whose answers on infection status were consistent with HER-SYS data and whose first infection was within the study period.

Post-COVID-19 Condition (Cases) and Persistent Symptoms (Controls)
We asked the participants about the presence of 26 symptoms that emerged during or after the first SARS-CoV-2 infection for cases and in July 2022 for controls.The symptoms were selected from the International Severe Acute Respiratory and Emerging Infection Consortium COVID-19 questionnaire.Symptoms were fever, cough, fatigue, sore throat, chest pain, anorexia, brain fog, difficulty concentrating, anosmia, ageusia, shortness of breath, hair loss, muscle weakness, palpitations, sleep disorder, rhinorrhea, headache, joint pain and swelling, muscle aches, nausea/vomiting, abdominal pain, skin rash, eye-related symptoms, dizziness, erectile dysfunction (male only), and menstrual change (female only) (26).If a symptom was present, we asked about its timing and duration: whether they had the symptom at illness onset or 3 months after infection (infected group only), whether they had it at the time of the survey, and whether the symptom persisted for ≥2 months.For those who affirmed they had any symptoms, we asked the extent to which the symptoms hindered daily life at the time of response using an 11-point scale from 0 (no effect) to 10 (extreme hindrance) and categorized those responses into 4 levels: 0, no effect; 1-3, mild hindrance; 4-6, moderate hindrance; and 7-10, serious hindrance.
For cases, we defined post-COVID-19 condition based on the World Health Organization (WHO) definition ( 27): a symptom that persisted for >2 months after the acute phase.For brain fog, difficulty concentrating, hair loss, and muscle weakness, we defined post-COVID-19 condition as symptoms having lasted >2 months during the observation period regardless of the timing because those symptoms develop in the subacute phase (17,28).For controls, we defined persistent symptoms as symptoms lasting >2 months experienced between July 2022 and the date of the survey.

Variables
We asked infected persons about the severity of acute COVID-19 and categorized them into 4 groups according to the WHO clinical severity scale: asymptomatic, mild (symptomatic but not admitted to the hospital), moderate (admitted to the hospital, required supplemental oxygen, or both), and severe (received mechanical ventilation or intensive care admission) (29).We counted the number of infections because some participants had been infected >1 time during the observation period.We also asked participants about their demographics (i.e., age at the answering date, sex, height, and weight), underlying medical conditions before the infection (or before July 2022 in the noninfected group), lifestyle, and socioeconomic status (e.g., household income and educational level).We calculated equivalized household income by dividing household income by the square root of the household size.For vaccination status, we extracted the vaccination date, vaccination type, and number of vaccinations from the municipality's Vaccination Record System.We substituted the questionnaire responses for missing values for 1,589 (10%) respondents (e.g., those who had moved from the original municipality).

Statistical Analysis
We determined the participants' characteristics according to their infection status and compared using the t-test for continuous variables and χ 2 test for categorical variables.We calculated the proportions of overall and each post-COVID-19 condition (cases) and persistent symptoms (controls).Using multivariable logistic regression analysis, we calculated the age-and sex-adjusted odds ratios of each symptom in the cases compared with the persistent symptoms in the controls as a reference.We also investigated the risk factors associated with post-COVID-19 condition among cases using multivariate logistic regression models.Model 1 comprised age group and sex; model 2, underlying medical conditions, body mass index, severity, and vaccination status before infection; and model 3, household income and educational level.We conducted multiple imputations using chained equations to account for missing data in model 3; the proportion of missing values in household income Post-COVID Condition during Omicron-Dominant Wave was 13.1%.We included all explanatory and outcome variables in the imputation model to create 50 imputed datasets.We also calculated the proportion of influence of post-COVID-19 condition on daily life.We defined statistical significance as a 2-sided p value <0.05.We used Stata version 17 MP software (Stata-Corp LLC, https://www.stata.com)for all analyses.

Results
A total of 51,822 persons were invited to participate in the study, of whom 18,183 responded to the questionnaire (response rate 35.1%).The response rate was higher in the infected group than in the noninfected group (37.3% vs. 32.9%,difference of 4.4% [95% CI 3.0%-5.8%]).The response rate was higher among female than male persons in all age groups of both infected and noninfected groups.Among male invitees, the difference in response rates between the infected and noninfected groups was large for age groups in their 50s (12.8% [95% CI 8.1%-17.5%])and 60s (8.5% [95% CI 1.6%-15.4%])(Table 1).
We excluded 3,473/18,183 respondents for responses of infectious status inconsistent with HER-SYS (answering different infection statuses or different diagnosis date) and reporting a prior infection and 9 because their records were missing data on age or symptoms.A total of 14,710 participants (8,392 cases and 6,318 controls) were eligible for the analysis (Figure 1).Mean age of all participants was 42.4 (SD 11.7) years; 8,502 (57.8%) participants were female and 6,087 (41.4%) male (Table 2).Mean age of case participants was 42.3 (SD 11.6) years; 4,802 (57.2%) case participants were female and 3,535 (42.1%) male.The mean follow-up period from SARS-CoV-2 infection to the response date was 167.9 (SD 14.5) days.Most cases (8,326 [99.2%] patients) demonstrated asymptomatic to mild disease, whereas 66 (0.8%) cases had moderate to severe disease.

Discussion
We conducted a population-based study using a selfreported questionnaire among adults in Japan who had confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection during July-August 2022, when the Omicron BA.5 subvariant was dominant.We compared their post-COVID-19 condition with concordant persistent symptoms among noninfected controls.The percentage of post-COVID-19 condition was 11.8% for cases, which was 2.3 times higher than the 5.5% of persistent symptoms noted in controls.The cases had a 6.2% higher prevalence of post-COVID-19 condition than the controls, suggesting that their symptoms were likely associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection.
Population-based studies of infected persons in the United Kingdom (n = 56,003) and the United States (n = 1,480) using smartphone applications reported that the prevalence post-COVID-19 condition associated with the Omicron variant, defined as symptoms lasting 4 weeks after the infection, was 4.5%-18.7%(12,23).Another population-based study of infected persons in the United States (n = 16,091) showed a prevalence of 11.2% ( 16) applying the WHO definition of the continuation or development of new symptoms 3 months after the initial SARS-CoV-2 infection, with those symptoms lasting for >2 months with no other explanation (27).
Although the definition of post-COVID-19 condition varies among previous studies (12,16,23,27), the proportion shown in our study is consistent with previous results.In those reports, post-COVID-19 condition was less prevalent among those infected during the Omicron variant-dominant wave than those infected during the previous waves with the ancestral strain predominance (16,23).However, although a multicenter prospective cohort study showed a higher proportion of severe fatigue and multiple symptoms at 3 months during the pre-Delta wave than that during the Delta and Omicron waves, the differences disappeared after accounting for sociodemographics and vaccination status (19).Systematic reviews suggested that vaccination before infection was associated with a lower risk of experiencing post-COVID-19 condition (30,31).Similarly, we found that vaccination before infection was associated with lesser post-COVID-19 condition.An in-depth study would clarify whether the reduced risk for post-COVID-19 condition during the Omicron wave was a result of the differences in strains, the effect of vaccination, or both.
Population-based large cohort studies in the United Kingdom (n = 606,434 and n = 486,149) and Germany (n = 11,710) reported that patients infected with previous-variant SARS-CoV-2 frequently experienced persistent symptoms such as fatigue, shortness of breath, concentration difficulties, memory disturbance, hair loss, and anosmia (5,7,32).Studies on patients infected with the Omicron variant, including a population-based study in the United States (n = 16,091) and hospital-based studies from China (n = 1,829) and India (n = 524), revealed that fatigue, brain fog, cough, and shortness of breath were frequently observed as condition (13,16,33).Our findings were comparable with previous results; we observed that post-COVID-19 condition after the Omicron-dominant epidemic frequently included neurologic symptoms such as difficulty concentrating, fatigue, and brain fog, in addition to cough and hair loss.In addition, those neurologic symptoms, as well as ageusia, anosmia, and muscle weakness, were distinctive symptoms among cases, who showed a higher OR than controls.Fatigue and neurocognitive impairment are reportedly related to impaired health recovery and reduced working capacity, even among young and middle-aged adults, after mild infection Post-COVID Condition during Omicron-Dominant Wave (7).Our results showed that ≈10% of those who had post-COVID-19 condition had persistent difficulties in daily living 4.5-7 months after the Omicron-dominant wave, which may have led to a deterioration in economic conditions or work productivity.Although background socioeconomic status was not associated with developing post-COVID-19 condition in this study, further investigation is required to evaluate the effect of post-COVID-19 condition on changes in economic conditions, schooling, and employment.
Large-scale population-based cohort studies on infection before the Omicron wave found that post-COVID-19 condition was more common in female persons, smokers, persons with obesity, those with more severe acute COVID-19 symptoms, and those who were deprived or had lower household income (5,7,32).Moreover, hospital-based studies in China (n = 21,799) and South Africa (n = 4,685) showed that the female sex, concurrent conditions, and severe acute illnesses were associated with post-COVID-19 condition in association with the Omicron variant (14,21), which was consistent with our findings.Although the results regarding age are unclear, some studies on the Omicron variant have suggested that the population 18-50 years of age has a higher risk for post-COVID-19 condition (21,34).Our study showed that post-COVID-19 condition for those infected during the Omicron-dominant epidemic was also more prevalent in middle-aged persons.A substantial proportion of the working-age population might have been affected; of 9 million persons infected during July-August 2022 in Japan, 31.2% were in their 30s and 40s (35).
The strengths of this study are the large number of participants including noninfected controls, the population-based approach, and the inclusion of all infected residents registered in the HER-SYS database within a municipality.We compared the infected persons with noninfected persons as a control and assessed the proportion of post-COVID-19 condition after the Omicron-dominant wave.
The first limitation of this study is that the response rate was higher among the infected group than the noninfected group overall.The infected participants may have been more interested in the survey on COVID-19 and post-COVID-19 condition.However, because we did not specify the purpose of the survey to investigate the post-COVID-19 condition but rather informed the participants that we aimed to investigate the effect of the pandemic on their health and daily lives, we believe that the influence of interest in post-COVID-19 condition on the responses to the questionnaire was small.Moreover, the response rate was higher for infected and noninfected female participants and middle-aged infected male participants; this finding could have been because those persons were inherently willing to answer questionnaires more than other persons, or because patients with those attributes (such as female sex and middle age) suffered more from persistent symptoms and had a higher motivation to answer the questionnaire.The results could be biased in both ways; however, we believe the effect was small because the higher odds of having post-COVID-19 condition in our study were consistent with findings from previous studies.Second, although we excluded those who self-reported having SARS-CoV-2 infection, it is possible that some infected persons were included in the controls, causing an underestimation of the difference in persistent symptoms between the cases and controls.Third, because the study was retrospective, recall bias may have occurred.In addition, because we relied on self-reporting, we could not rule out the possibility that the participants' symptoms were caused by conditions other than COVID-19.However, we estimated the symptoms attributable to COVID-19 by comparing with a noninfected control group.Finally, although this study included all infected persons registered in the nationally established registry system, caution is needed to generalize the results of this single-city analysis to other populations in Japan.
In this population-based study, 11.8% of patients with COVID-19 had post-COVID-19 condition during the Omicron-dominant wave; this rate was 2.3 times higher than the persistent symptoms among noninfected controls.Among the cases, female sex, underlying medical conditions, and severity of acute COVID-19 were associated with having post-COVID-19 condition.We recommend a longer follow-up study of the effects on daily life and socioeconomic status after infection during the Omicron-dominant wave.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Flowchart of participant selection in study of prevalence and risk factors for post-COVID-19 condition during Omicron BA.5-dominant wave, Japan.Of 29,276 residents 20-69 years of age identified in the municipal HER-SYS database as infected with COVID-19, we selected a total of 25,911 participants; we extracted the same number of age-and sex-matched noninfected residents from the Basic Residence Registration System to serve as the control group.HER-SYS, Health Center Real-time Information-sharing System on COVID-19.

Figure 2 .
Figure 2. Prevalence and age-and sex-adjusted odds ratios of persistent symptoms in cases compared with controls in study of prevalence and risk factors for post-COVID-19 condition during Omicron BA.5-dominant wave, Japan.All cases and controls are included in the multivariable logistic regression analysis to estimate the odds ratio of developing post-COVID-19 condition among cases compared with controls adjusting for age (as a continuous variable) and sex.

Table 2 .
Characteristics of participants in study of prevalence and risk factors for post-COVID-19 condition during BA.BMI, body mass index; NA, not applicable.†Includes patients who turned 70 years of age between the participant selection and survey periods.‡Respiratory diseases included interstitial lung diseases, asthma, and chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases.Heart diseases included myocardial infarction, angina, heart failure, arrhythmia, myocarditis, and cardiomyopathy.Mental disorder included anxiety and depression.§Number of vaccinations administered until 14 d before infection (cases) or before June 2022 (controls).
*Values are no.(%) except as indicated.Continuous variables were compared by using t-tests; categorical variables were compared by using χ 2 tests.

Table 3 .
Factors associated with the prevalence and risk factors for post-COVID-19 condition during BA.5 Omicron-dominant wave, Japan* Associations were determined by using multivariable logistic regression models for 8,392 infected persons (cases).Model 1 included age (as a categorical variable) and sex; model 2 added preexisting medical conditions (factor variable), BMI (categorical variable), severity of acute COVID-19 (categorical variable), and vaccination before infection (factor variable); model 3 added household income and education level (categorical variables).BMI, body mass index; NA, not applicable; OR, odds ratio.†Number of cases who had post-COVID-19 condition. *